Samsung's recent Galaxy Note 4 apparently edged out the recent Apple iPhone 6 Plus in terms of display quality, even though the analyst reviewing it basically called Apple's displays the best he's seen to date.
In a report released Monday, DisplayMate's Raymond Soneira--who does nothing more than test smartphone displays, by the way--called the iPhone 6 Plus display the "best performing smartphone LCD display that we have ever tested," Soneira wrote. "The iPhone 6 Plus has raised the bar for top LCD display performance up by a notch," he added.
High praise indeed for the iPhone 6 Plus. But that doesn't make the iPhone 6's display the best, period--an odd little caveat that may inspire a new round of back-and-forth between Samsung and Apple fanboys. "We recently gave the Samsung Galaxy Note 4 our overall Best Smartphone Display award, and for the time being that continues for all of the reasons originally mentioned there," Soneira wrote in his report.
Apple's iPhone 6 uses a 1334x750, 326-ppi pixel display, while the iPhone 6 Plus has a 1920x1080 pixel display with 401 ppi. Apple calls both displays 'Retina HD," and executives made a big deal at the iPhone 6 launch describing how good they look.
Still, Soneira wasn't nearly as effusive about the display quality of the smaller iPhone 6. "The display on the iPhone 6 is none-the-less still a Very Good display, and most buyers will be happy with its performance, but it's somewhat disappointing that Apple went for satisfactory as opposed to the best," Soneira wrote. "Maybe that was done for intentional product differentiation with the iPhone 6 Plus, or perhaps to improve their margins... With a 1920x1080 display the iPhone 6 would have taken the crown."
According to DisplayMate's tests, the iPhone 6 Plus breaks all sorts of records, including the highest peak brightness, lowest screen reflectance, highest (true) contrast ration, highest contrast in ambient light, and more. But it doesn't exceed competitors in terms of resolution, pixels per inch, and absolute color accuracy.
Still, both displays should satisfy casual users and creative types alike. With a nearly perfect 99 percent sRGB color gamut for the iPhone 6 and 101 percent for the iPhone 6 Plus, the displays will be almost be perfectly color accurate. And in a nod to anyone who uses their phone outside in the bright summer sun (which is, naturally, everyone) the two phones combine of high screen brightness and low screen reflectance, critical to outdoor performance. Specifically, they both provide 550 cd/m2 luminance, DisplayMate found.
In general, the two iPhone 6 displays are also both more power-efficient than other full-HD LCD smartphones. But the Note 4 outclassed the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus when used to view a mixture of different images, consuming 21 percent less power. If the display was simply powered on to a white screen, however (such with a flash light app) the two iPhone displays would consume 45 percent less power than the Note 4.
Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.