Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

Ron Miller: Spain's link tax taxes my patience

Ron Miller | Aug. 5, 2014
The so-called Google tax is a desperate and wrongheaded gambit to save traditional newspapers.

The humble hyperlink, the building block of the World Wide Web, is under attack in Spain. When Sir Tim Berners-Lee defined his vision of the Web, it was to be a set of documents joined together by the hyperlink. The hyperlink is the essence of all we do here, which is why a new Spanish law is so vexing.

The law has its ambiguities, but in essence, it would tax aggregators such as Google News for linking to an article published by a daily newspaper. How is this misguided? Let us count the ways.

First of all, the Web has existed, at least conceptually, since the early 1990s. It's ludicrous to react to it in 2014 as though it had just appeared out of thin air.

Second, it is completely wrongheaded to say that entities like Google News links are suppressing the news business. That stance ignores the obvious benefits that linking brings, in the form of hundreds or thousands of readers who otherwise would not have been aware of the article's existence. In fact, if you found this column via a search engine, I welcome you with open arms.

Third, the law disregards the fact that the Web is based on the free and unfettered sharing of information via linking, as well as the fact that a whole generation of online publications and services have been built based on this idea.

Fourth, the Spanish economy is a shambles. The government can ill afford to start messing with a part of the economy that actually works in an effort to protect a dying industry through protectionist legislation.

This law was promoted by Spain's daily newspaper association, and it applies only to its members. Now, as the Quartz article that I linked to above notes, all websites have the option of not being indexed by search engines by using a mechanism called robots.txt to hide from the search bots. If Spain's daily newspapers really had a problem with their articles being discoverable by Google and others, they could easily opt out. Apparently, they don't want to do that.

That's because they probably don't want to risk losing some of their websites' traffic. But they do want to find another source of revenue. So this seems like one of those have-your-cake-and-eat-it-too situations. Look, we all know that the way the Web works is that the more people who link to your content, the better, because that increases the likelihood that more people will come to your site, giving your content more value to advertisers. Eyeballs equal money in the online content game, and legislating limitations by adding cost to linking reduces one of the key ways sites get traffic.

 

1  2  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.