Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

U.S. court ruling a warning to companies on workers' Facebook privacy

Antone Gonsalves | Sept. 16, 2013
Decision expected to be influential because few courts have tackled how law such as the Stored Communications Act applies to social media

A recent federal court ruling is a warning to companies that workers' non-public Facebook postings are private and uninvited employers have no right to read them.

The ruling, handed down last month, stemmed from a lawsuit filed by a paramedic against Monmouth-Ocean Hospital Service Corp. (MONOC) in New Jersey. Deborah Ehling was disciplined after posting on her Facebook wall a comment criticising Washington, D.C., paramedics' handling of a deadly shooting at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum.

The U.S. District Court decision is significant because it is one of very few rulings addressing whether Facebook postings meant only for users' "friends" are protected under the federal Stored Communications Act. Passed in 1986, the act extends protection to electronic communications that are configured to be private.

"The message that we're getting here is that the courts will take very seriously the privacy interests of someone who is using social media and designates it as private communications," Robert Quackenboss, a partner in the labor employment group of the law firm Hunton & Williams, said on Thursday.

While the ruling only applies to the parties in the case, the decision is expected to be influential because so few courts have addressed the issue of how privacy protections apply to social media. Because the district court was on relatively virgin ground, it was particularly thoughtful in addressing the legal issues.

"The first federal court to do so with sound reasoning ends up being very persuasive to other courts that take up the matter subsequently," Quackenboss said.

MONOC suspended Ehling for a post that followed the June 2009 shooting, in which white supremacist James W. von Brunn, 88, opened fire in the Holocaust museum, killing a guard and sending visitors, including children, diving for cover. Other guards returned fire, wounding von Brunn in the head.

Ehling's post, which was not explained in the court's decision, read, in part, "I want to say 2 things to the DC medics. 1. WHAT WERE YOU THINKING? and 2. This was your opportunity to really make a difference! WTF!!!! And to the other guards....go to target practice."

In suspending Ehling, who was president of the Professional Emergency Medical Services Association union at the time, MONOC officials said the posting was a "deliberate disregard for patient safety."

Ehling had configured Facebook to show her postings only to roughly 300 "friends," which included co-workers, but not management. Unbeknownst to Ehling, Tim Ronco, another paramedic who was on her friends list, was taking screenshots of her postings and sending them to MONOC manager Andrew Caruso, who then sent them to Stacy Quagliana, executive director of administration at MONOC, according to the court ruling.


1  2  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.