A government watchdog group tasked with overseeing whether actions the President's executive office takes to combat terrorism don't throw civil liberties overboard in the process is taking aim at the National Security Agency's "PRISM" data-collection surveillance program.
The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB) is the federal agency within the executive branch that's expected to independently review anti-terrorism efforts to see if they comply with established law and to ensure "liberty concerns" are addressed. Some think a privacy group so close to the President would only be a "rubber-stamp" operation. But the PCLOB surprised more than a few when its recent 238-page report bluntly condemned the NSA surveillance program collecting bulk telephony call records as illegal, saying it should be shut down. Now the PCLOB is turning its attention to "PRISM," the purported NSA surveillance program that has come to light through leaks to the media from former NSA contractor Edward Snowden.
"Our responsibility is to provide advice to the President," said David Medine, chair of PCLOB., speaking on a panel at the recent RSA Conference in San Francisco. He said the group hopes to be able to issue its report on PRISM within the next few months. The group is obtaining information about PRISM from various agencies, including the NSA, and the private sector. Medine notes the PCLOB, whose five members have top-secret clearances, can gain access to surveillance court decisions, agency officials and can even see program demonstrations.
PRISM is a secret NSA program in which high-tech giants such as Microsoft, Google, Yahoo and Facebook, among others, must cooperate by providing data on end users to the NSA. PRISM has been described in various ways by journalists, mainly from The Guardian, New York Times and Washington Post, who were given top-secret documents from Snowden directly, though sometimes only PowerPoint slides.
"There's a lot of inaccurate reporting in the media" Medine remarked about what he's seen in the news about PRISM in comparison to what the PCLOB is learning. Though he didn't go into detail about how news reporting on PRISM may be off the mark, he suggested that news stories are sometimes simply reporting older information as current, for example.
In any event, the PCLOB hopes to issue its own findings on the NSA PRISM program fairly soon, though the PCLOB itself, composed of lawyers, is somewhat hobbled by the fact that only Medine is a full-time member and the four other board members, split between Democrat and Republican party representation, do this part-time while holding down regular jobs. This part-time aspect of running the board puts a strain on what can be done, some PCLOB members acknowledge, though some, such as James Dempsey, think it's a good model for oversight.
Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.