Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

Are mix tapes legally protected? Spotify suit questions originality of compilations

Evan Dashevsky | Sept. 6, 2013
Is track order a legally-protected concept? The courts will have to sort this one out.

spotify

Here's a question that 1995-You may be very interested in: Can you copyright a mix tape filled with tracks not created by you, but that you meticulously curated? That's the basic question at the heart of a lawsuit filed in UK Courts against Spotify.

The British dance music empire Ministry of Sound (MoS) has made a mint over the past two decades selling curated compilations, which have sold over 50 million copies to date. The songs featured on the well-regarded compilations are all legally licensed, but MoS does not own many of the digital rights outright, therefore artists are allowed to license their work separately to streaming venues such as Spotify. And that's where things get messy.

Like fellow Britons in Radiohead, MoS has opted not to license their compilations albums to services like Spotify, being of the opinion that record labels don't get a fair shake out of the relationship. Of course, many of the tracks from MoS' compliations independently appear on Spotify where they are available for listening for free by any user. Spotify allows users to create their own publically searchable playlists of songs culled from the platform's vast library of streamable tracks. Given that freedom, some Spotify users have recreated MoS' compilations as Spotify playlists, often incorporating the "Ministry of Sound" name into the title.

For example, a very quick search through Spotify turned up the user-curated playlist "Ministry Essentials: Deep House" (Spotify link), which happens to have many of the same tracks on MoS' compilation Deep House — Ministy of Sound. The playlist and official compilation are not exact matches (in fact, the Spotify playlist has quite a few more tracks), but there is a lot of crossover. Therefore, a consumer has a choice between accessing the Spotify playlist for free or purchasing the album for £6 (around $9.38) on Amazon or $10 on iTunes.

Unlike the tracks' artists, MoS does not receive any royalties generated from Spotify's revenue stream. In an op-ed appearing in The Guardian, MoS chief executive Lohan Presencer commented "You won't find our compilation albums on Spotify. Why not? Because its business model does not recognise that our products have any material value. It doesn't consider them worth licensing."

Mr. Lohan went on to explain why his record label has opted to sue Spotify in a case currently working its way through the UK courts. "Users of the service were copying our compilations. They were posting them as their own playlists and calling them 'Ministry of Sound'. We assumed it was an oversight on Spotify's part and contacted the company to request it remove the offending playlists. It declined, claiming there was no infringement and it wasn't its responsibility to police its users."

 

1  2  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.