Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

MacBook Pro Vs. Dell XPS: is MacBook Pro worth the dough?

Tony Bradley | Feb. 25, 2011
Apple unveiled a completely refreshed line of MacBook Pro laptops this week. The new MacBook Pros have a variety of improvements over their predecessors, and some unique features only available from Apple. But, as with all things Apple you will pay a premium for having the half-eaten fruit logo on the case of your laptop.

FRAMINGHAM, 25 FEBRUARY 2011 - Apple (AAPL) unveiled a completely refreshed line of MacBook Pro laptops this week. The new MacBook Pros have a variety of improvements over their predecessors, and some unique features only available from Apple. But, as with all things Apple you will pay a premium for having the half-eaten fruit logo on the case of your laptop.

First--a brief summary of what is new and improved in the MacBook Pro lineup. The MacBook Pro series is now built on Intel (INTC) processors from the Sandy Bridge line, including quad-core Core i7 processors for the 15 and 17-inch models. They have improved Facetime HD webcams for video chat, the new Intel connectivity platform Thunderbolt (formerly known as Light Peak), and an SDXC card slot which is capable of addressing 2TB of SD memory (if such a thing exists someday).

The bonus is that Apple made all of these performance improvements and feature additions without changing the base price of the various MacBook Pro models. Not too shabby. I feel a bit sorry for a friend of mine who just bought two MacBook Pros a couple weeks ago. Missed the boat on that one.

All of that sounds great, but if you are standing in Best Buy (BBY) trying to make a purchasing decision and weighing out the specs of different laptops to determine which is the best value, the MacBook Pro is unlikely to come out on top.

Let's compare the 15-inch options. If you filter the options on the bestbuy.com Web site to narrow down the base specs--quad -core Core i7 processor, 4GB of RAM, and a 500GB hard drive--you get eight different laptops that fit the description. They start at $830--less than half the base price of the 15-inch MacBook pro, and some of them come with 6GB of RAM rather than 4GB.

The Dell XPS laptop has more memory--with 6GB, and more storage capacity--with a 640GB hard drive, than the base 15-inch MacBook Pro. It has a recordable Blu-Ray drive, NVidia (NVDA) graphics with 2GB of memory and HDMI output, a 9-in-1 card reader slot that is SDXC capable, a 2MP HD webcam, and two USB 3.0 ports. It is only 1.3 inches thick, weighs in at just under six pounds, and costs $1150.

The 15-inch MacBook Pro has a faster core i7 processor, and both thinner--at only one inch thick, and lighter by a couple ounces. It does have the aforementioned Thunderbolt port, but there are virtually no devices available to take advantage of that yet, while there are tons of USB 3.0 devices out there. Aside from that, the two laptops seem fairly evenly matched--except the MacBook Pro is $1812.

 

1  2  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.