Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

Got enterprise software? You're probably due for an audit

Katherine Noyes | Jan. 27, 2016
Vendors are turning up the heat to boost their revenue, licensing experts warn.

Money
For software vendors, license audits mean additional revenue. Credit: Michelle Maher

If you run software for a business, take note: Vendors are watching you closely.

Corporate users are expected to pay in full for all the ways they use a vendor's software, and on what systems, and for all the people who use it, and maybe more. Complicating matters further, the rules can often change.

It's not easy for enterprises to keep track of every penny, but vendors do. Tales of the widely dreaded "compliance audit" are increasingly common.

"Vendors are putting more pressure on customers," said Craig Guarente, co-founder and CEO of Palisade Compliance, which helps Oracle customers negotiate with the database giant. "They're definitely using audits to get leverage with their clients."

For example, a vendor may question the company's compliance in one area and use that as an excuse to call for a brand-new cloud contract. The message: Sign that contract, and those issues will be overlooked.

"As software vendors hunt for top-line growth, they turn to license audits as a means of generating additional revenue," said analyst Frank Scavo of Strativa. "Some go so far as to sue their customers for years or decades of alleged underpayment."

Licenses are often unclear in many ways: Some fees are based on the number of users, others on CPUs, others on transaction counts, and others on different metrics altogether. SAP's licensing terms, for example, include the squishy concept of "indirect access." Oracle often zeroes in on the ambiguities associated with virtualization.

Even if a company has controls in place, "they can hit you with something spurious, tentative or made up," agreed Duncan Jones, a vice president with Forrester. "They're sort of like, don't ask, don't tell, thanks for the money."

A Tuesday report from software asset management company Flexera underscores those trends. A full 65 percent of enterprises surveyed for the report have faced a software license compliance audit by a vendor within the past year; 44 percent paid $100,000 or more in so-called "true-up" costs as a result.

Organizations typically do not have enough licenses for some software, but they also often pay maintenance on software they are underutilizing, Scavo said.

"I’m working with one client right now that went through a significant downsizing several years ago," he noted. "Although they are back on a growth path, they are paying for more ERP licenses than their current user headcount requires. The vendor thus far has been uncooperative in allowing them to cut back their license count."

The problem has become particularly acute as vendors have begun shifting their marketing and sales efforts to the cloud, even as they continue to rely on traditional license revenue to keep investors happy.

 

1  2  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.