Subscribe / Unsubscribe Enewsletters | Login | Register

Pencil Banner

You want to know who has access to what? Good luck

Roger A. Grimes | March 26, 2014
Access control sounds simple, until you try to tease out rights and permissions for every user in your environment

There's a dirty little secret in the computer security world that makes the dream of least-privilege access control very hard to attain: It's often literally impossible to determine who has what level of access to which objects.

How so? The access privileges granted to a person or any other security subject -- such as another computer, service, daemon, and so on -- are determined by the permissions configured on each individual computer and each individual object, such as file, folder, registry key, memory area, and more. Both can be difficult to check, but the latter is much more difficult, thanks to scale.

Your basic access-control model
Overall access policies are defined for every computer. These include the types of access that are allowed, either for all users or specific sets of users. In Windows, more than a dozen different types of general access can be defined: logging on locally, using RDP, over the network, anonymously.

After access has been granted, the objects a user can view, read, delete, or modify are controlled by the individual permissions stored along with each object. In Windows, these permissions are called access-control entries, and the collection of all access-control entries is called an access-control list.

When the user attempts to access a particular object, Windows first checks to see if the user is allowed to access the computer via the method employed, whether local, network, or otherwise. Then it compares the access-control list's set of permissions to the access requested. If they match, the user is allowed to access the object.

That's the local machine. When the user requests write access to a particular file on a remote computer over the network, the user's "security token" -- holding his or her authenticated identity and group memberships -- is passed to the remote operating system along with the user's desired access request. A security mechanism in the remote operating system then queries the file's access-control list. The access-control list defines what users and groups are allowed to work with the object and with what permissions (read, write, and so on).

Let's say the user account is allowed read access only, but the user belongs to a group that is allowed write access. In most modern operating systems, that group membership would enable the user to write to the file. This is a pretty straightforward process -- or so it seems.

Who can do what
Now suppose a company wants to know all about a particular user's access privileges. Unless that has been meticulously documented, every computer system and every object on every computer system in the environment must be queried to generate an accurate list.

Now repeat this process for every user and computer within your environment. Even if you limit queries to important computers and important files, you can easily end up with hundreds of billions of individual queries and answers, even in a small-to-midsize business.

 

1  2  3  Next Page 

Sign up for CIO Asia eNewsletters.